Davey y su pandilla se disponen a investigar al misterioso asesino de Cape May, pero, ¿qué pasará cuando descubran que el principal sospechoso es un policÃa vecino de Davey?
 | Graham Verchere | Davey Armstrong |
| Judah Lewis | Tommy 'Eats' Eaton |
| Caleb Emery | Dale 'Woody' Woodworth |
| Cory Gruter-Andrew | Curtis Farraday |
| Tiera Skovbye | Nikki Kaszuba |
| Rich Sommer | Wayne Mackey |
| Jason Gray-Stanford | Randall Armstrong |
| Shauna Johannesen | Sheila Armstrong |
| William MacDonald | Sheriff Caldwell |
| Harrison Houde | Bobby Coker |
| Aren Buchholz | Kyle |
| Susie Castillo | Brenda Woodworth |
| Reilly Jacob | Dewitt |
| Jaiven Natt | Joven |
| J. Alex Brinson | Cole |
